357 For Black Bear Protection


I found/ordered some 45 LC 260 gr, sjhp,at 1200 fps, from Georgia Arms. Persons living in bear country, while no doubt better served for personal protection by handguns larger than. 357 magnum bullets…you get the picture. 357 defense loads are trimmed to 1. There was one failure and one successful defense with a. so which of these is better protection? should i take both? if i have to shoot one should i aim for the head or body?. The 10mm is a newcomer in the hunting world, but has become a big player in the market for bear hunters or anyone needing extra power. Efficacy of Firearms for Bear Deterrence in Alaska that only those proficient in firearms use should rely on them for protection in bear country. SMITH,1 Wildlife Sciences Program, Faculty of Plant and Wildlife Sciences, Brigham Young University, 451 WIDB, Provo, UT 84602, USA STEPHEN HERRERO, Environmental Science Program, Faculty of Environmental Design, University of Calgary, Calgary, AB, Canada T2N 1N4. The grizzly was killed. i was talking about black bear too no brownies. In mark3smle test you can see the. I used to know a guy who hunted black bear with a. Not this will be for a 4. –-(Ammoland. 357 Magnum at 100 yards is only 3. I would take the. 45 has a heavier grain bullet but the. The only time I carry the 357 loads is while sleeping in black bear country, where I use jacketed rounds. For that job, there's none better than outfitter Wayne Bosowicz. It works for deer so I wouldnt see why not for black bear. It worked great. I'm of the bigger is better theory when it comes to bears and handguns. 357 magnum, but it does not have the knock down power needed to slam a 400 lb Black Bear down. She didn’t have a firearm with her at the time, and she lost both arms as a result of the attack. of 45,or 41,and you will have ammo for both at the same time. The point here is not to prove you can stop a charging bear with a smaller, inadequate cartridge. 10mm against a brown bear is nothing more than a deterrent, regardless of the cartridge. The mid-range trajectory of the. 357 Magnum was used for bear defense, and here is where we find our failure. This will give the best odds should a defense be needed. 357 diameter Pistol Bullet for your reloading recipe. As far as available bullet weights, velocity, and energy; it's comparable to. 44's with a 250 grain bullet at 1200 fps. From your first post I assumed you were going to be shooting it out of a handgun but now see the twist of a Marlin rifle. 357 Magnum will hammer everything up to deer and black bear. What are your opinions on. There are numerous guns used both for hunting bears and protection against being attacked by them. There was one failure and one successful defense with a. I don't want the extra weight of large frame while I'm hunting and hiking in the mountains. I just got a Judge ss 6. 41mag should be fine for black bear i use a 5. 357 was the caliber of choice for black bear back then,. No hollow point ammo. Soon i will be traveling hikingbiking in black bear country and i am planning on taking my 4 629 with me. I do want something that will protect against bear, likely black bear since I don't foresee going anywhere near Grizzly country. At this time, I am not set up to hand load. Those that are successful in Alaska are those who are flexible, and allow the reality of life in Alaska to shape their dreams, vs. Again, using spray is a far more effective way of improving your odds; a review of its use in Alaska found a 98% success rate, with no fatalities. I have killed 4-5 blacks with a 357. 44 Magnum or a 10mm. 10mm and 45acp for hunting or bear protection. Critical Defense ® Lite™ ammunition offers an effective, reduced recoil option for any shooter looking to minimize felt recoil of their lightweight, compact personal protection firearm. Outside the context of that stock joke, I had never heard of anyone seriously intending to use a revolver on a bear until I started reading prepper articles extolling the virtues of. 357 was engineered to kill people through steel car doors from the 30s and has literally twice the kinetic energy of an ordinary 9mm load when it's loaded to full power. 357 Magnum vs 9mm. Gee guys, Black Bear are not that hard to kill. I quickly learned that with part one and part two of this series on self-defense ammunition. 45 has a heavier grain bullet but the. 9mm for black bear? This is a discussion on 9mm for black bear? within the Ammo and Reloading forums, part of the Gun Forum category; Without arguing the merits of carrying a gun while backpacking (a whole topic in and of itself), I'm curious what round you guys would pick. I had a book about handgun hunting written in the 70s when I was a kid and it seemed like. For that job, there's none better than outfitter Wayne Bosowicz. Each of these rounds has a long history and pedigree of efficacy in the realm of self-defense, so that both are good carry rounds is. Ideal for you for pigs in cover. for brown/griz protection. 454 Casull range. com)- On the Internet, and in print, many people claim that pistols lack efficacy in defending. 357 Magnum loaded with Buffalo Bore 180 grain (Heavy) Magnums. If you want to carry a hand gun a 41,or 45 colt would be perfect. That is unless one is a fan of the. That in no way makes a. 45 ACP, even 9MM. 357 Magnum provides adequate protection against grizzly bears or not. 357 has less recoil than 44 mag so in theory you would have a better chance of actually placing a good shot. Critical Defense® Lite. The weight of this revolver is a little heavier, which helps stabilize and control recoil. I am going elk hunting this year in western Wyoming, and there are both grissly and black bear in our hunting area. Im planning on some family trips to the smokies. I'm considering getting a 2-3" barreled. 357 Magnum 1911 , I want to share some ballistics and history on this powerhouse self-defense cartridge and why many gun carriers trust their lives with it each day of the year. It charges, and you have time to pull out your sidearm. Rounds are loaded with HPR HyperClean® technology that combines clean-burning powders and primers to ensure firearms keep functioning when you're in the backcountry for extended periods of time. Ammo is available in just about any weight/velocity you want. For the purpose of self-defense, the largest caliber, most portable gun is ideal. This will give the best odds should a defense be needed. 212) bullets in full power loads should be effective against large predators. 357 magnum that I got for fun shooting and a camp rifle; dad is up in age and has lost some body mass and I want setup the. He writes that "In solid form it is a great choice for general applications, including long range shooting, hunting or busting into the brain cavity of an irritated grizzly!" This is the bullet that my wife uses in her S&W 586 for black bear protection around our home. 357 Magnum was introduced by Smith and Wesson in 1934. Since then, Doubletap has developed a reputation for powerful, reliable and accurate ammunition loaded with a variety of premium bullet options. 45 is bigger but it does not have the penetration of the. with 158-gr. The 10mm is a newcomer in the hunting world, but has become a big player in the market for bear hunters or anyone needing extra power. SMITH,1 Wildlife Sciences Program, Faculty of Plant and Wildlife Sciences, Brigham Young University, 451 WIDB, Provo, UT 84602, USA STEPHEN HERRERO, Environmental Science Program, Faculty of Environmental Design, University of Calgary, Calgary, AB, Canada T2N 1N4. 357 Magnum revolver with a DA/SA action and stainless steel medium frame. There are numerous guns used both for hunting bears and protection against being attacked by them. 357 is a little on the light side. 50 muzzle loader), I carry a single shot shotgun (20 or 12),as bear protection when wilderness camping and canoeing and feel confident it will work fine. Well, I'll start by telling you I have NEVER been a big fan of the 10mm and I have loved the. When he got me in good light, he dropped me and ran off! I'm ugly, you see. The carcass of a black bear that was found in UT in 1975 was so big that it was sent to the Smithsonian to verify that it was in fact a black bear. 357 Mag ammo handgun 180 grains AmmoSeek. is on the lighter end of the cartridge spectrum. Bear grabs you while you are in your tent - bear spray will be useless and that is an outright feeding attack - fight for your life. 32 Win Special into a black bear than was running at him before it went down - he thought the bear was confused, not attacking. They follow their noses, and use their mental maps of the landscape to locate food sources, which are in a constant state of flux, from season to season and year to year. 327 Magnum, the new Ruger GP100 fires the. In order to save human lives Chuke performs a ballistic test on an actual bear head. The nose is just too dang long. That goes for hunting. Some experts say any big- bore cartridge that throws a solid bullet weighing 200 grains or more at 1000 fps. 357 Magnum against the threat of bears and such in backpacking and camping. Hi everyone, I am new to the forum and am looking for some advise on factory 44 mag ammo for black bear defense. Source: 1911Forum, Reddit AR-15. Anything smaller will not do the job. I want something small and light but "good enough" for up to black bear, with the primary emphasis being self defense. That is unless one is a fan of the. Black bear common senseoptions: 3-6″. Weather you are buying bulk 357 Magnum ammunition for target shooting or personal protection choose from our. 357mag what would be best for black bear or boar defense, FMJ or JHP or JSP Bullets? I won't be hunting them, but if I happen to come around a bend in the trail and a Sow is about to charge me because I am between her and her cub or piglets, I am just looking for the most effective round. 357 is the most street proven self-defense cartridge available. If a Brown Bear attacks you, cover your head and curl up into a fetal position. You need something you can shoot accurately very quickly and probably more than once. 357 in the forehead won't instantly stop a charging black bear, there's just too much bone to penetrate. Black bear are different and size matters (the bear's and the bullets). With offering cheap ammo price & fast shipping services. But if you search the internet enough you can find a study that will say what you wish. I will assume you are looking for grizzly protection, since you didn't specify the bear and black bears are relatively shy. of 45,or 41,and you will have ammo for both at the same time. 45 is bigger but it does not have the penetration of the. Black bear common senseoptions: 3-6″. Seriously, any good personal defense handgun caliber will kill a Black Bear,. And yes, a carefully aimed and well-placed. Field Shooting Positions That Work Hunters who are new to handgun hunting often struggle with holding the gun steady. The bad news is a heart shot won't instantly stop a charging bear. Black Talon can dispatch 350-ish pound black bear. A black bear's skull is only a little thicker than a large dog. Alaska Magazine had an article four or five years back about bear protection and boiled down the numbers. At this point I feel like I would be more effective with the 10mm's I shoot better and more often. 45 for back up in black bear country?. It is also a good idea to keep an eye out for fresh bear scat so you have an idea if bears are in the area. We also want the heaviest and fastest hard cast round we can find for penetration. If you want to carry a hand gun a 41,or 45 colt would be perfect. I have personally taken part or witnessed a black bear fall dead to a. It seems that a lot of folks are interested in the question of whether the. Violent attacks usually only last a few minutes but can be prolonged if the victim fights back. Last fall I killed a black bear with a Ruger Bisley 45 colt. 357 mag, 44 mag and my 336 in 35 Remington. 357 magnum that I got for fun shooting and a camp rifle; dad is up in age and has lost some body mass and I want setup the. Gonna do that with a 45LC or. he used a Colt in 38 super and killed a bunch of black bear and cougers out of trees with it. The bear only weighed 175 lbs (estimate by check station) it was pretty small but still absorbed an incredible amount of lead and managed to run for a couple of miles up and down steep south western VA mountains. That in no way makes a. I know everybody thinks they are going to go John Wick on a bear and overwhelm him with a multitude of bullets, but that ignores the second bear truth: Bear attacks happen very fast. Accurate, powerful and modest recoil. All of this research has convinced me that the 10MM Auto in the Glock platform anyway, is "on all fours" with heavy 357 Magnum loads, factory 41 Magnum loads and the Garrett Cartridges (T) 44 Magnum Defender loads for Field Protection and Self-Defense in Alaska. The bad news is a heart shot won't instantly stop a charging bear. I am frequently up in the Berkshires and there are Black Bear up there. Spraying the pepper into the air will irritate the bear's sensitive nose and it will run away. I am frequently up in the Berkshires and there are Black Bear up there. 357 mag over the. 9mm for bear defense. 357 Magnum’s recoil easy with this piece. 44 Magnum will be fine. While a strong 357 mag revolver with 180 or 200 gr cast can be considered as the bottom rung for bear protection, the 357 sig can't handle the heavyweight bullets. The bad news is a heart shot won't instantly stop a charging bear. 357 Magnum Guns And Ammo Weapons Guns Hunting Supplies Smith Wesson 38 Special Tactical Knives Matte Black Firearms Smith & Wesson M&P Performance Center 357 Mag Rubber Grip Black Finish 170292 - BN Hunting Supplies - America's largest online firearms and accessories mall. 357 Mag would be much better, I would think, than a 9mm for what you are doing. I also discovered that Hornady. The 10mm loaded to the gills and fired from a longer specialty barrel, can approach a hot loaded. Geographical Survey, was severely mauled by a black bear in the Yukon wilderness. Shop trailers for sale by Sure-trac, Bear Track Products, Criterion, Eagle Trailer, Bear Track, Mirage Trailers, and more. As it happens, there are some limited instances of these rounds being used successfully on animals. Sadly, it is quite the hefty gun to tote around when fishing or hiking. i was talking about black bear too no brownies. Bear defense plays an important part in Alaska because bear attacks, as expected, are common. 357 Magnum revolver, provided I can get one for a reasonable price and can buy a box or two of ammo at the same time. The idea of using a semi-auto handgun in a cartridge designed for self-defense against humans is ballistic folly. 357 were successful. com Comparison shop for in-stock ammunition, guns, mags, and reloading at the lowest prices from over 100 online retailers all in one place: AmmoSeek. 357 defense loads are trimmed to 1. 357 S&W Magnum Bear Defense Bear Ammo Ammo Ammunition Eric Conn. 38 brass loaded with excessively high pressure. 9mm for bear defense. I use it for deer and he uses it for black bear situations like yours. Trust HSM Bear loads for your protection from dangerous game. 357 for years and years, but for your indicated target (Black Bear), I'd think you wouldn't have much trouble dispatching a Black Bear with the 10mm loads you mentioned, BUTgiven the enviroment you have describedI'd almost rather the bear eat my entire RV before I'd squeeze off a round in a. 30-06 or at the very least, a. In this article, we will review the best guns for bear hunting. 357 mag revolver. 357 mag is about the minimum in power for protection against large predators or against large game. The Big Bear is chambered in. It charges, and you have time to pull out your sidearm. 45 for bear "defense". 357 would be better because of it having more stopping power. Looking to get the Mossberg 500 security / field combo, but I am wondering about the field barrel. Or even species. so which of these is better protection? should i take both? if i have to shoot one should i aim for the head or body?. The Ruger GP-100 ($650) is a 6 shot. Would any of these work on a black bear and if so which caliber. Many deer have been killed with a. Friday, July 30, 2010 10:29:00 AM. 35 Rem, and I wouldn't hesitate for a second to use the 200 grain bullet on a black bear. Most people. Odd question and I do know that these are not ideal calibers for the job. 357 Magnum, though it took four shots before it went down. But such is not the case. Try shooting through a 6-inch pine tree with the 357 rifle and then with a 357 revolver; you will see a big difference. Black bears come in red, brown, blonde, and black color phases, but they are all black bear species and should be considered "black bears" regardless of color phase. 357 big enough for black bear?I checked The taylor Knock down factor and it said it was good up too 100 yards. The 357 Magnum is the most powerful cartridge that the average shooter will be able to control, given a handgun of sufficient weight and modest practice. Just use a decent bullet and u will be just fine. But if a sprayed bear veers off, the encounter is over. with 158-gr. 357 out of a 4"+ revolver will deal with just about any black bear, grizzly and brown bear something in the. If this is good enough for hunting them, then it sure must be good enough for defense. But I was thinking about picking up a black powder revolver and curious about its power and accuracy for defense against the very unlikely and mostly make believe bear or cougar attack. You aim for his head, the bullet penetrates his skull and scrambles his brain and he dies. I mentioned a few minutes ago that this has been my black bear gun for when we go on hikes as of late, since we just moved to the Blue Ridge Mountains in NC. should stop them in a few. for well over half a century, where it was just as effective in that role as it was in the hands of generations of hunters who brought home food for the table using it. Violent attacks usually only last a few minutes but can be prolonged if the victim fights back. All bears are intelligent animals and should be respected. I live in serious black bear countryand the grizzly population is on a definite rise. The 10mm penetration was around 16 inches. 357 magnum that I will take when I go hiking. Bear attacks are seldom but once in a while they do happen. 44 magnum carbine that is light. I had gritty hounds that would grab ass, so the action is fast. Black Bear which. He grabbed me up and took off. When you think of shooting a bear, a rifle of some kind might be the first gun that comes to mind as the best option. The best types of bear guns fall into two distinct categories; guns for hunting and guns for self-defense. 22 rifle, but you would be in a predicament if it were a brown bear. 357 sig vs. Shot placement is important though. Dogs, coyotes, racoons, deer, pigs and so on. My buddy took his first blackbear with a 10mm outside of anchorage. My wife usually keeps the bear spray close by, and although bear attacks are extremely rare, I think it would be quite useful in a more likely event such as a wild dog/cat or a drunk at a campground etc If I ever buy a handgun specifically for protection in the woods it will be a Glock 20. The only thing that makes the. Single-Action Defense "The solid, heavy frame of an SA revolver can contain and control more power than most semi-auto pistols…in rural areas that power can be effectively used to overcome barriers and longer ranges. Loaded with hollow points in either. Most people. 357 Magnum was used for bear defense, and here is where we find our failure. I also do lots of hiking in surrounding areas of high grizzly density (around Yellowstone and Glacier National Parks, etc. 380) are a bit weak the most popular are. In 1978, Cynthia Dusel-Bacon, a geologist with U. We are proud to continue our legacy as an American-family owned and operated business. 357 should be enough for black bear. 178) to 250 grain (SD. 45 Long Colt only. 357 magnum is borderline for any big game hunting, and while it can kill a bear, it is anything but ideal. Geographical Survey, was severely mauled by a black bear in the Yukon wilderness. 357 was the caliber of choice for black bear back then,. Comments on stopping power and the. A lot of folks carry the 44 mag as well, but you dont need all that for the bears. 357 Magnum Revolver:-Selection of a firearm is primarily based on what it will be used for. 327 Magnum, the new Ruger GP100 fires the. Is it sufficient for self defense against a black bear?. Bear spray would be first line of defense for an open charge or challenge as it should put up a boundary parameter to prevent physical contact. 357 Mag For Bear or 300 lb black bear? Also is this self defense or hunting? use a. 38 Special/. Also confused on rifled barrels and what ammo can be used in them. I would not recommend a. It is great as a backup and for personal defense, but not for hunting. Trust HSM Bear loads for your protection from dangerous game. I tried searching the internet and all I kept getting was recipes for hand loads. My fav wheel gun is my. I would probably pick it over a. Soon i will be traveling hikingbiking in black bear country and i am planning on taking my 4 629 with me. 44 Magnum or a 10mm. 357 Magnum being used on grizzly bears. 22 rifle, but you would be in a predicament if it were a brown bear. Modern Self-Defense:. Just use a decent bullet and u will be just fine. I think the 9mm would be ok for that use. 38 Special is an excellent cartridge for self-defense and training. The Big Bear is a California legal version of Bond Arms derringer true pocket pistol. 41mag should be fine for black bear i use a 5. 50 Alaskan 12-Gauge Slugs. This is a parody of all the ammunition test videos on the internet that try to be super scientific- the. There were three instances in which. Bear spray would be first line of defense for an open charge or challenge as it should put up a boundary parameter to prevent physical contact. , legal now for use in Ohio and parts of Michigan. I live in serious black bear countryand the grizzly population is on a definite rise. This is a discussion on 357 magnum bear guns and bear loads. 357 Magnum being used on grizzly bears. With that same gun you can also sling mild. 45 is bigger but it does not have the penetration of the. 357 for bear defense and felt fine, knowing I wouldnt use it but at near point blank ranges aiming at the bears. This is a PSA test due to the recent fatalities so that people may make an. For black bear the 357 and 45 might be OK. I'm sure that with proper shot placement you could dispatch a bear with a. 357 loads that one would choose for black bears. They range from 150-pound black bears to 1,300-pound brown bears. I want something small and light but "good enough" for up to black bear, with the primary emphasis being self defense. 10mm against a brown bear is nothing more than a deterrent, regardless of the cartridge. 45 has a heavier grain bullet but the. I would not recommend a. The 10mm loaded to the gills and fired from a longer specialty barrel, can approach a hot loaded. 357 magnum that I will take when I go hiking. This round should take down a black bear. In a perfect world I would have a Semi-Auto shotgun loaded with slugs too. Most also agree that a lighter rifle is better for serious backcountry hunting, and the lightest can be found in a bolt-action configuration. Defense Against Bears with Pistols: 97% Success rate, 37 incidents by Caliber. , it was hard to decide which one. old kid that has wanted a “Bond Arms” derringer for several yrs. Gil Horman cabin or trail gun for protection against dangerous game. Anything smaller will not do the job. Maybe as a backup, but that's it. It's been quite a while since my last bear hunting trip, but some things never change. Oldtime black bear hunters say that any load that throws at least a 200-grain or bigger solid bullet at 1000 fps or more will take any bear in the woods. The bear would run at any moment, once he saw or smelled the man. If you wanted to change your rifle then get one in the cal. A video of the encounter, seen nearly 4 million times, serves as a reminder of. Was carrying my. Don't let the puny gun inappropriately influence your "bravery" w. 357 Magnum and discuss some of the misconceptions as well as the viability of this classic as an all around survival round for everything from personal protection to hunting and woods defense. The point here is not to prove you can stop a charging bear with a smaller, inadequate cartridge. 45 is bigger but it does not have the penetration of the. best ammo for bear/cougar protection. When I say Buffalo Bore gets the 9mm into the realm of. 357 were successful. 357, and penetration isn't that much less. Kill the bear with a large deliver of bullets or play dead. 357 with laser sight grip in a belt holster. 357 Magnum loaded with heavy for caliber bonded, based jacketed soft-point or hard cast lead bullets will get the job done. 357 for black bear protection either. I hunt partridge with my. This is a great load for deer, hog, black bear, and woods protection with your 41 Mag! Caliber:. He told me that his G20 is for protection, although he has recently gotten a G40. These 6-shot, hexagonal-cylinder Rhino revolvers are available in 2-inch, 3-inch, 4-inch, 5-inch and 6-inch barrel lengths and in black anodized, nickel-plated, and “gold” finish, with prices ranging from $1,089 to. Might want to look at those. Handguns were. 45 ACP, even 9MM. 357 Magnum Revolver:-Selection of a firearm is primarily based on what it will be used for. One such hunter was Richard Wesley, who late last month survived a black bear attack while turkey hunting in Ontario. 357 magnum in eastern Washington. --(Ammoland. For use in the lower 48 states, a. within the Range Reports forums, part of the Gunner Forum category; Too windy, today, for serious air gun work, so we headed to the range to do some revolver testing with my favorite factory heavy 357. I want something small and light but "good enough" for up to black bear, with the primary emphasis being self defense. 9mm for black bear? This is a discussion on 9mm for black bear? within the Ammo and Reloading forums, part of the Gun Forum category; Without arguing the merits of carrying a gun while backpacking (a whole topic in and of itself), I'm curious what round you guys would pick. 200gr hardcast in. I once had a bear come thru my yard at night. 178) to 250 grain (SD. I would not recommend a. 357 sig vs. Considering taking my 7 shot. I use it for deer and he uses it for black bear situations like yours. i dont see anyone write about bear problems but i know they will out there.